Not Quite Yet

This time of year always comes quietly. I call these weeks “bridge weeks”: it’s warm during the day and tomatoes and corn are still at the markets, but the light is a touch more golden and it’s chilly enough in the mornings and evenings to grab your closest sweater. While fall is my favorite season, I find myself going inward a bit in September, wanting to experience the change of seasons without the Internet or  TV forcing it upon me, or Starbucks announcing what seasonal drink I’d likely crave at any given time. We’re fickle people, aren’t we? One week eating stone fruits and discussing the dog days of summer and the next diving head-on into pumpkin breads and cookies. This is why I don’t read many food blogs at the very beginning of fall because I’m not quite ready to jump right into pumpkin breads and cookies. Here at our house, there are still tomatoes to slice, warm walks to take, and backyard picnic table with my name on it.

I recently picked up the most recent (Fall 2012) issue of Gastronomica while playing hooky at Elliot Bay Books with Sam last week. There is a lot to think about in the issue, from articles on food blogs and feminism to an exploration of the cultural significance of lard in the Ukraine, but there’s also a sweet little poem called “Sharing Mason Jars” by Dee Hobsbawn-Smith that touches on those quiet moments between friends in the kitchen just sitting, catching up, “dividing the day, the peaches, the jokes.” The poem closes with, “Linking arms, we pour cream into each other’s coffee/and admire how we have contained/summer’s fading light.” It’s that simple, really: not letting the summer-ness of these days get away from us in the rush to welcome fall.

So here we have tomatoes. Perfect heirloom tomatoes that were begging to be folded into something  substantial enough to have for dinner last weekend. It’s rustic, so don’t expect a savory pie with a crisp crust that slices into perfectly neat, upright slices. There will be messy tomatoes and gooey cheese, and that’s what makes it so wonderful. The crust is a little more puffy and biscuity than traditional pie crust thanks to the leavening and the buttermilk. I’m actually so looking forward to using the same exact crust for a quiche or tart very soon — it’s delightfully soft on the bottom yet crisp around the edges. I played around with the flours, using a good amount of rye flour which I love for its dark earthiness. If you haven’t tried rye flour in pie crusts or scones yet, it’s relatively easy to find in well-stocked grocery stores and bakes up a mean, tasty pie or gallete, as the case may be.

A few quick notes on the recipe: Because the dough has more liquid than other doughs, it can be a little tough to handle. The recipe says to roll it in between two pieces of plastic wrap, but I always find that fussy. I say to work quickly, use flour liberally on the surface where you work, and don’t be afraid to patch away when little (or big) cracks or holes emerge as you’re laying the round of dough into the pie pan. It happened with me here, and you’d never know. Just snip a little piece of extra dough and lightly press it into a spot that needs it. This is such a rustic pie, it really doesn’t matter so try not to stress about the dough on this one. It’s not supposed to be perfect. For tomatoes, I used heirlooms but they do have more moisture than, say, a Roma tomato so do slice them relatively thinly and don’t skip the step where you let them drain. The bottom crust of the pie was pleasantly soft, but I could imagine it veering on soggy if you didn’t let the tomatoes drain well.

Quick Aside: If you’re curious about whole grains and whole-grain flours, it’s Whole Grain Week over on The Kitchn, and I’m focusing on a lot of breakfast-type things, so I’ll see you there. And hey, we’ll do something fall-ish soon. Until then, I’ll be donning flip-flops and working on the laptop in the backyard.

Whole Grain Tomato Cheddar Pie

Whole Grain Tomato Cheddar Pie

  • Yield: Serves 6-8
  • Prep time: 25 mins
  • Cook time: 40 mins
  • Inactive time: 1 hr 30 mins
  • Total time: 2 hrs 35 mins

This recipe originally appeared in Bon Appetit last summer, and I’ve had my eyes on it ever since. I lightened it up this by replacing the mayonnaise with plain yogurt. I also swapped 1/2 of the all-purpose white-flour with the ever-wonderful rye flour, added a touch less sugar and a smattering of chives. The result is a savory, delightful mess of a tomato pie. I can’t help but think how wonderful this would be with fresh corn kernels from 1 ear of summer corn or quickly-sauteed zucchini slices. This pie has room for you to add a little of this and a little of that (sauteed kale  or spinach would be nice, too)

Adapted from: Bon Appetit 

Ingredients

For the Crust:

1 cup all-purpose flour
1 cup rye flour
1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
6 tablespoons (3/4 stick) chilled, unsalted butter, cut into 1/2-inch cubes
1 cup buttermilk

For the Filling:

2 pounds ripe tomatoes, cored and cut into 1/4-inch slices
2 1/2 cups coarsely grated sharp cheddar (8-9 oz)
1/4 cup finely grated parmesan (1/2 oz)
1 scallion, trimmed, chopped
1/2 cup plain yogurt
1 teaspoon fresh or dried chopped chives
1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
1 teaspoon sugar
1 teaspoon kosher salt
1/2 teaspoon freshly-ground black pepper
2 tablespoons course-ground cornmeal

Instructions

To make the crust: Whisk first five ingredients together in a medium bowl. Using your fingertips, rub in butter until coarse meal forms and some small lumps remain. Using a fork, stir in buttermilk  to ensure that all the dry ingredients have been combined with the wet. The dough will be sticky but should also be uniform. Form 1 single disk and wrap in plastic wrap. Refrigerate for at least one hour and up to one day.

To make the filling/pie: Lay tomatoes in a single layer on a baking sheet lined with 2 layers of paper towels. Place another 2 layers of paper towels on top of tomatoes. Let stand for at least 30 minutes to drain away some of the liquid.

Preheat oven to 425 F. On a well-floured surface, roll dough out into an 11″ round. Try to work quickly as the dough will be more difficult the more it warms ups. Invert dough onto pie dish and nestle it in so the edges all but right up to the pie pan. Try not to handle too much. If the dough tears or develops snags, simply patch them and move on–it’s a rustic pie and no one will ever know.

Toss both cheeses in a medium bowl until evenly incorporated. Reserve 1/4 cup of cheese for the very top. Whisk scallion, yogurt, chives, vinegar, sugar, salt, and pepper in a small bowl. Sprinkle cornmeal evenly over bottom of crust, then top with 1/2 cup of cheese mixture. Arrange 1/3 of tomatoes over cheese, overlapping as needed. Spread half of yogurt mixture (about 1/3 cup) over top as best you can. Repeat layering with 1 cup of cheese mixture, 1/2 of remaining tomato slices and remaining yogurt mixture. Sprinkle with remaining cheese. Fold overhanging crust up and over edges of tomato slices. Crimp as desired.

Bake until pie crust is golden and cheese has melted and turned slightly golden, 35-40 minutes. let pie cool at least 1 hour and up to 3 before slicing/serving. While the pie is best enjoyed the day its made, cover and refrigerate and serve the next da

Comments

  1. Sam

    Dear Megan, Long-time reader, occasional commenter here, writing to say that I'd rather enjoyed said tomato cheddar tart, and found it rather brilliant, exactly on such a summer day as this great holdout of a season did produce. I thought I might also mention that there are two names on that picnic table in the backyard. That's right.

    Great crust! Great tomatoes! Great lunch!
    -Sam!

  2. la domestique

    That tomato-cheddar pie looks so good! Last week I did a frittata much like this, but with Parmesan and thyme. I love the look of that rustic crust, though.

  3. tea_austen

    I have been loving these late summer days, and feeling lucky to get them. The tart looks gorgeous, that summery sunset lake shot even better.

    Enjoy the days!

    1. megang

      Thanks, Tara! Yes, I'm saving these days up for the moments in February where I start to wonder why the heck people live in a place that gets dark at 4. Hope you had a good week, friend.

  4. Mardi (eat. live. travel. write)

    Oh I love the sound of this pie/ tart… I am JUST getting to grips with pastry and will have to give this one a go. Gorgeous!

    1. megang

      Thanks, Mardi! This dough isn't the easiest, but like I said, you can just patch away and no one will ever know. Hope you're well. xx, m

  5. susan

    I am so excited to try this. On family vacations on the Outer Banks in North Carolina this is a favorite from a deli in Duck! My sister is visiting so I'm making it this weekend.

    And Megan, I would love to see you!

    1. megang

      I'd love that too, Susan! Emailing you now ...

  6. eric G

    Sounds like a fantastic alternative to our tasty meal last night of homemade heirloom tomato soup and grilled cheese sandwiches (on sourdough but I like the rye idea too). I may just have to bake a pie! I have to wonder if the kitchen & better half can handle the mess I'd make! :)

    1. megang

      Eric- Oh, I'm sure that better half would understand. I've been craving tomato soup something fierce lately, so your meal sounds pretty wonderful. Bake a pie! Do it! Miss you guys, m

  7. dervla @ The Curator

    yay for the not quite end of summer! Glad you're not jumping into pumpkins like everyone else. I'm not ready either.

  8. Sarah

    Fall is my favorite season, too, and I tend to jump the gun this time of year and want to scurry through the last weeks of summer and immerse myself in autumn. Thank you for the reminder to stay in the present and look around!

  9. Mary

    Beautiful photography. Would like that pie now.

  10. Nicole @ Eat This Poem

    I'll have to pick up that issue to read the full poem. The excerpts you shared sounded lovely!

  11. kickpleat

    I've made something similar but I like the sound of this and will definitely pick up some local tomatoes soon to give this a go. Hooray for playing hooky and late summer sun.

  12. Ashley

    I love the NW this time of year, especially time spent on the deck.

    How's your garden? Each time you pop-up in my feed reader I wonder how it's going.

    1. megang

      Hi, Ashley! The garden is good ... winding down a bit. We have kale, carrots and beets now. We also have cabbage that has literally taken since May to finally grow some little cabbages. And it's taking up an entire raised bed all on its own. I have no clue why anyone would ever grow cabbage! I'm excited for the kale to get a touch larger and to harvest those beets. Happy Friday, m

  13. Jessica

    Yum! Might try it this weekend.

  14. molly

    Gastronomica! I had forgotten about Gastronomica. Read it for years. Before I had three. Thanks for the reminder; feels like a postcard from an old friend.

    Happy still-summer to you, Megan :)

    M

  15. Stephanie

    I love this post, and I feel the same way about the last few weeks of summer. I want to relish them and not hurry too quickly into fall, even though I adore it.
    This savory pie looks scrumptious -- thank you so much for sharing!

  16. lori

    Megan, This post summed up how I've been feeling lately and this pie looks fantastic. I have a big bowl of tomatoes that now have a purpose...

  17. Kasey

    You said what I've been thinking for weeks! I keep feeling like I need to file away all of my summer recipes -for peaches, tomatoes, and corn...but truth be told, they're some of the best I've tasted all summer and I can't help continuing to enjoy them well into September. Love this idea for a savory pie! xo

  18. Jess

    We're still in tomato mode here, too. Feels good. Enjoy these days. xo.

  19. savorysaltysweet

    Messy tomatoes and gooey cheese are two of my most favorite things. This looks just perfect.

  20. Diana Mieczan

    I simply love heirloom tomatoes and your pie looks totally scrumptious:) Btw: the beautiful light in the second photo makes me swoon:) xo

  21. Ellie@Fit for the Soul

    Wow this looks amazingly delish and rich. I wouldn't mind having some of this on a nice porch looking at the sky and green fields or something of that sort~haha. I'm daydreaming here!

  22. Kimberley

    Ugh, love this. That poem is wonderful. I so agree with you. September is a funny month that way. And while I am, indeed, dreaming of pumpkin-centric foods in all their glory, I am not at all ready to let go of tomatoes, not until they're completely done.

  23. Gayle

    Our local Edible Boston had a very similar recipe in their Fall tomato feature. Can't wait to try this one. - Gayle

  24. laura

    I made this recipe recently for my folks during a visit home to Virginia and they loved it. Enjoyed outside, sun setting. Thanks for being an inspiration, Megan! Take care.

  25. K

    Although this is an old post, I can't help but sympathize with it! Summer is rapidly dwindling in the city of brotherly love and the fall semester is just around the corner--too soon!

    To get back to the recipe--it is by far one of the greatest things I've made/eaten in quite some time!

    Thank you!

    1. megang

      I'm so glad you enjoyed the recipe! It's about time I make that again around here - so delicious. Thank you for the comment, Megan

  26. robin lewis

    any make-ahead/freeze/bake later tips?

  27. robin lewis

    p.s. if freezing isn't a good idea, can this pie at least be made ahead and baked after a few hours or so (or overnite) after assembling? always searching for make-ahead dishes that make good gifts to help others out...

    1. megang

      Hi Robin-
      Oh, I hear you on the make-ahead dinner front, for sure. You know, I bake dozens of different kinds of sweet pies and freeze them pre and post bake, but I wouldn't feel super confident doing so with this tomato pie mainly because of the tricky moisture balance. If anything, I'd try freezing it BEFORE you bake it off; I think that'd be far more successful than baking and then freezing. If you try it, do let me know how it goes ... I just find baking with juicy summer tomatoes can be tricky enough as it is. Enjoy the week + thank you for your note, Megan

  28. robin lewis

    this was really really delicious, thank you. i doubled the recipe, though, and maybe i shouldn't have doubled the kosher salt...? that would be my only question: i love salt and salty dishes, but i wonder of doubling it in this case might have been a tad too much salt...still, delicious.

    1. megang

      Hi, Robin-
      So happy you enjoyed the recipe. It's always hard to get a recipe perfect when doubling, tripling etc ... especially with dishes like pie etc. I find this the most with salt and spices -- they're the ones that tend to take a little finessing. If I were you, I'd do 1 1/2 tsp. kosher salt when you double it and see how that tastes. Luckily, if it feels a little under-salted to you, you could always add a few flakes of Maldons at the end, to top. Best of luck and enjoy the recipe! ~Megan

Join the Discussion

Holiday Baking

Dark and Spicy Pumpkin Loaf

Dark and Spicy Pumpkin Loaf

It turns out that returning from a sunny honeymoon to a rather rainy, dark stretch of Seattle fall hasn't been the easiest transition. Sam and I have been struggling a little to find our groove with work projects and even simple routines like cooking meals for one another and getting out of the easy daily ruts that can happen to us all. When we were traveling, we made some new vows to each other -- ways we can keep the fall and winter from feeling a bit gloomy, as tends to happen at a certain point living in the Pacific Northwest (for me, at least): from weekly wine tastings at our neighborhood wine shop to going on more lake walks. And I suppose that's one of the most energizing and invigorating parts about travel, isn't it? The opposite of the daily rut: the constant newness and discovery around every corner. One of my favorite small moments in Italy took place at a cafe in Naples when I accidentally ordered the wrong pastry and, instead, was brought this funny looking cousin of a croissant. We had a wonderfully sunny little table with strong cappuccino, and, disappointed by my lack of ordering prowess, I tried the ugly pastry only to discover my new favorite treat of all time (and the only one I can't pronounce): the sfogliatelle. I couldn't stop talking about this pastry, its thick flaky layers wrapped around a light, citrus-flecked sweet ricotta filling. It was like nothing I'd ever tried -- the perfect marriage of interesting textures and flavors. I became a woman obsessed. I began to see them displayed on every street corner; I researched their origin back at the hotel room, and started to look up recipes for how to recreate them at home. And the reason for the fascination was obviously that they were delicious. But even more: I'm so immersed in the food writing world that I rarely get a chance to discover a dish or a restaurant on my own without hearing tell of it first. And while a long way away from that Italian cafe, I had a similar feeling this week as I scanned the pages of Alice Medrich's new book, Flavor Flours, and baked up a loaf of her beautiful fall pumpkin loaf: Discovery, newness, delight!

Read More
Nibby Chocolate Buckwheat Shortbread

Nibby Chocolate Buckwheat Shortbread

I had every intention of starting a new tradition this year and hosting a cookie swap with some of our local friends, but somehow the season really got the best of me and it just hasn't happened. But! That hasn't stopped me from getting a head start on holiday baking; I posted a photo on Instagram the other day of some of my very favorite holiday cookbooks, and asked if there was a way we could all just take the whole week off to bake instead of work. Judging from the responses, it seems I'm not the only one who thinks this would be a really great idea. But back here in reality, cookie baking is relegated to later evenings or, I hope, this weekend we'll find some time to eek in a few batches (the recipe for Sam's mom's Nutmeg Logs is up next, and I'm set on making gingerbread men to take with us down to the Bay Area). Right now on our countertop, we've got a batch of these crumbly, chocolatey, whole grain shortbread that have proven to be a big hit. The ingredient list is small and simple, the technique foolproof, and I think they're a real standout in a sea of holiday cookies.

Read More
And Just Like That

And Just Like That

Hello from the other side! I realize we haven't been back here for a few weeks, and I'm sorry for dropping into a little black hole. My cookbook deadline was Monday, so I've been a writing and editing machine, stepping away from the computer to occasionally clean the house like a crazy person or throw together a most random lunch or dinner. But somehow it all came together although there was something strangely anti-climactic about sending it off: In the days when you'd print out your manuscript and have to walk to the post office and seal it up carefully to send to the publisher, I imagine it would feel much more ceremonial and important --you could stroll out of the building and do a cartwheel. Or high-five a fellow customer on your way out. Instead, I was sitting in our dining room on an incredibly rainy, dark Monday afternoon unable to hit "send."  My sister Zoe told me to just close my eyes and do it. Sam gave me the thumbs up. So around 3 p.m. that's what I did. With the click of a button, just like that: it was finished.

Read More
Soft and Chewy Ginger Cookies (Plus a Treat for You)

Soft and Chewy Ginger Cookies (Plus a Treat for You)

Strolling New York City streets during the height of fall when all the leaves are changing and golden light glints off the brownstone windows. This is what I envisioned when I bought tickets to attend my cousin's September wedding earlier this month: Sam and I would extend the trip for a good day or two so we could experience a little bit of fall in the city. We'd finally eat at Prune and have scones and coffee at Buvette, as we always do. Sam wanted to take me to Russ and Daughters, and we'd try to sneak in a new bakery or ice cream shop for good measure. Well, as some of you likely know, my thinking on the weather was premature. New York City fall had yet to descend and, instead, we ambled around the city in a mix of humidity and rain. When we returned home I found myself excited about the crisp evening air, and the fact that the tree across the street had turned a rusty shade of amber. It was time to do a little baking. 

Read More
Pear Gingerbread for Early Mornings

Pear Gingerbread for Early Mornings

We've been waking up early these days with baby Oliver. I've always been a morning person, so this isn't particularly challenging for me -- although the middle of the night feedings have proven to be really tough. There has been a lot of finessing of sleep schedules and figuring out how Sam and I can both get enough to function well the following day. And just when we think we have it down ("gosh, aren't we lucky we have a baby that sleeps?"), everything changes. When I was in the final weeks of pregnancy and would talk about how I couldn't wait for the baby to be here, all of my friends with kids would advise me to sleep as much as possible -- and now I get it. I should've napped more. I should've listened. In getting up at odd times throughout the night with Oliver, I've had the chance to occasionally see some really brilliant sunrises (although not this past week which has been a particularly dark one in Seattle); I've made up some wacky baby tunes that I'm happy no one else can hear; and I generally have a good hour in which I can put him in the sling and walk briskly around the house trying to soothe him back to sleep while also putting away a dish or two or making a quick cup of coffee. In that hour, I can usually get something productive done and this past weekend that something was pear gingerbread.

Read More